ABSTRACT

Selection and management of coating systems for the interior and/or exterior of a water tank is no easy feat. Owners must consider different factors including cost, lifecycle, and environmental impact when making decisions about coatings.

The process of selecting a coating system and maintenance plan for a steel water tank is often based solely on personal opinions about the proposed system's value. These opinions can be limited in scope and hard to verify with data. In recent years, the industry has recognized life cycle costing (LCC) as a method of decision-making for owners and engineers to determine the most economical and sustainable solution for their asset in terms of corrosion protection.

AWWA1 D102-21, Coating Steel Water-Storage Tanks, recommends the aid of an economic review using a life cycle costing analysis (LCCA) to determine the best suited course of action for coating and maintaining a steel welded water tank.

A collection of multiple industry papers and resources, including the recently published paper "Separating Fact from Fiction – AWWA D102 Coating Service Life" provide unbiased historical data on which coating service life and costing can be extrapolated. Using these resources, an accurate life cycle analysis (LCA) can be completed for any water tank asset.

After reading this paper, the reader will have a general understanding of where to locate accurate resources for critical inputs on water tanks, the life cycle costing and environmental analysis process, and how to use a life cycle analysis as a tool for asset management.

INTRODUCTION

A life cycle costing analysis (LCCA) is the process of compiling cost estimates for each coating system option in combination with the expected life span of each of those options. In general terms, the lowest cost per year of service is the most economical choice. This LCCA process can be paired with an environmental impact analysis to evaluate the sustainability considerations of managing the water tank asset. One of the most commonly addressed factors in an environment life cycle assessment is a calculation of the greenhouse gas emissions associated with a process, presented in equivalent CO2 emissions. Reliability and accuracy of the inputs in this process are critical since misconceptions or inaccurate data can alter the outcome of the analysis.

This content is only available via PDF.
You can access this article if you purchase or spend a download.