Failure data from compression and extension testing of Dunnville sandstone and Webatuck dolomite were analyzed using three different criteria: Mohr-Coulomb, Hoek-Brown, and Paul-Mohr-Coulomb. An emphasis was placed on the details of the failure criteria under tensile-compressive loading conditions, which was possible due to a dog-bone specimen geometry. Tension cut-offs were implemented when using Mohr-Coulomb and Paul-Mohr-Coulomb due to unrealistic predictions of (theoretical) tensile strength. It was determined that under tensile-compressive loading conditions, a tension cut-off provided a better match than Hoek-Brown to the data for the two rock types examined. Hoek-Brown overestimates the uniaxial tensile strength by a factor between 2-3 and has the greatest overall least absolute residual error in the low mean stress region.

This content is only available via PDF.
You can access this article if you purchase or spend a download.