Abstract:

In their ARMA 2015 paper “Numerical Modeling of Roof Support Plans at 4-Way Coal Mine Intersections” authors presented an approach to quantify reinforcement effect of a roof support plan over a designated area based on critical failure strains in tension, compression and shear in the immediate roof, pillars and immediate floor strata [1]. The above led authors to evaluate roof support plans at two coal mines in Illinois for an idealized four-way intersection with one cut corner [2]. In this paper authors use the above approach to analyze the effects of two variables on intersection stability: 1) Effect of error in estimating GSI on assessing stability of intersection, and 2) Effect of mining cut sequence in relation to the orientation of pre-mining maximum compressive stress. First, sensitivity of critical strain zones is analyzed due to an error in assessed GSI values used for estimating the Hoek-Brown failure properties for different lithologies. Then, the effect of two cut sequences is analyzed on the stability of the intersection. The developed 3-D numerical model was calibrated using in-mine measurements of convergence and instrumented bolt loads. Differential pre-mining horizontal stress field result in high shearing strains at pillar corners. The immediate roof strata in the N-S entry was subjected to high compressive strains of about 4 mm/m while low confining stress in the ribs resulted in high tensile strains. Contours of yielded zones in coal ribs extended 0.8 m (2.5 ft.) in the E-W direction that increased to 1.2 m (4 ft.) at the base of the pillar with failure occurring in the shear mode. Pillar corners and 0.4 m (1.25 ft.) of the ribs along the N-S entry fail in shear and tension. Some pillar settlement with shear failure occurs in the weak floor around all corners.

Introduction

Room-and-pillar and longwall mining systems develop underground excavations whose stability must be considered over their service lives. The primary concern is around intersections since 70-80% of roof falls in US coal mines typically occur there. An analysis of 2004 to 2008 roof falls in Illinois mines also showed that over 80% of these falls were concentrated at intersections [3].

Rock bolts are extensively used as primary and secondary support elements in coal mines around the globe. Typical cost of roof control in Illinois mines constitutes about 7-20% of the production cost depending upon site specific geo-mining conditions. In spite of considerable previous research on the topic, there is a need to improve the scientific basis for the design of roof control plans. Most of the currently practiced bolting layouts have been developed based on field experience rather than on a scientific basis. Therefore, it would be a contribution to develop an approach that can identify critical areas of instability around an intersection and assess the efficiency of a roof control plan. The critical zones can then be reinforced with appropriate support elements to develop sound roof control plans that will control the rock mass deformations around intersections.

This content is only available via PDF.
You can access this article if you purchase or spend a download.